Ghost Global: the dark side of consistency

More of the same. It can be good. It can be bad. Using examples from the Magic Markets Premium research library, I explain this further.

Imagine this: you visit a new coffee shop for the first time and have the best cappuccino of your entire life. The next day, you revisit the coffee shop, hoping for a similarly good experience, only to find that the entire menu has been changed.

“Keep on keeping on”: a business strategy 

The cappuccino is still there and is just as good, but now it’s called an “extra-tall espresso with foam” and it costs R1 more than before. Alright, you might think, it’s a little strange but at least the product is still good.

You return the next day to find that all of the waiters have been replaced by AI-enhanced serving trolleys. The coffee is still excellent though, so you come back on the fourth day, only to discover that the coffee shop is now a mobile cart and they only accept payment in Bitcoin. 

Would you go back to see what surprises await you on the fifth day?

Running a business means eternally see-sawing between keeping your customer base engaged and interested, and offering something that they can rely on. Consistency is more than a buzzword here: it’s one of the most basic things that your business needs to master in order to gain the trust of its customers (not to mention investors and shareholders). Nobody likes a rollercoaster. Well, except swing traders.

Does that mean that consistency is the opposite of innovation? It doesn’t have to be. As with all things in business, success is often found in those tricky grey areas between two extremes. 

Our Magic Markets Premium research library is full of examples of businesses that have innovated themselves out of the game – but there are also those who have stagnated beyond relevance. Consistency is as important to a business as water is to human being’s survival.

Just remember that too much water can still drown you. 

If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it

One example of consistency done right comes from our very recent recap report on Visa

Visa goes beyond being just a card in your pocket. Behind the scenes, it operates a massive global payments network, enabling the card to function worldwide. The farther the money travels, the more revenue the network generates. This is why Visa benefits greatly from cross-border travel and has been likened to having a royalty on global trade.

Its robust business model is widely recognised, and its valuation reflects that strength.

Here a strong case is made for consistency. Visa has a focused management team, a strong brand and most importantly, a product that addresses a need that consumers will always have. So while innovations are coming down the pipeline – think AI and the clever Visa+ concept – there’s really not that much left for the Visa team to do other than to keep this ship on course. This is what they do best, unlike Hasbro (covered in the same recap show) that is in the midst of a turnaround strategy.

The dangers of falling asleep at the wheel

Of course, there’s always the danger of being too consistent, as illustrated particularly well by our recent report on Tupperware.

The ultimate irony is that it is the longevity of the Tupperware brand that is working against it here. The older a company gets, the more challenging it becomes to think creatively and adapt. Keeping up with the changing times requires constant innovation, and once a company falls behind the curve, it seems almost impossible that they will catch up. 

The pandemic presented a prime opportunity for Tupperware to innovate. Its traditional distribution model – those iconic Tupperware parties – came to an abrupt halt, as even the most determined sales representatives would struggle to get people to attend socially distanced Tupperware parties while wearing masks. The brand needed to embrace digital platforms swiftly, a move that should have been made at least a decade ago. 

And that is exactly the point where the slow-acting chickens came home to roost. 

The brand’s failure to innovate earlier has left it struggling to navigate the digital landscape and compete effectively with newer, more agile companies. Tupperware’s longevity and adherence to its traditional methods have become significant obstacles in an era where rapid change and innovation are key.

To regain relevance and capture new markets, Tupperware must now make a concerted effort to overhaul its business model. This means leveraging digital platforms, investing in e-commerce capabilities, and adopting a more dynamic approach to marketing and sales.

Sadly, it also means hiring advisors to help it survive. The brand is good. The business model isn’t.

With well over 80 research reports on global stocks available in the library, a subscription to Magic Markets Premium for just R99/month gives you access to an exceptional knowledge base that has been built since we launched in 2021. Now that’s what we call the right kind of consistency!

There is no minimum monthly commitment and you can choose to access the reports in written or podcast format – whatever floats your boat. Sign up here and get ready to learn about global companies>>> 

1 comment

  1. Why don’t you guys do a monthly top 10 list that you are personally invested in. It can be 5 each as an example. It is goog to subscribe to your research, but where are you invested.

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles

Boring business billions

The world’s richest people aren’t always building apps or chasing disruption. Here are three stories that reveal how unglamorous industries keep minting billionaires. From billboards to pig farming and car mats, there are many ways to make it big.

Ghost Bites (AB InBev | Jubilee Metals | HCI | Schroder European Real Estate)

With all the news from the first week of January 2026 included in one Ghost Bites, you'll find deal news at AB InBev, Jubilee Metals and HCI. There's also a valuation update at Schroder European Real Estate.

Why ETFs Play a Vital Role in Private Markets

Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have emerged as a transformative solution, for public markets and also as a strategic bridge to private market exposure. The border between traditional and alternative asset management is dissolving. Clients are driving the convergence, seeking integrated solutions that blend public and private exposures. Duma Mxenge of Satrix explains.

Ghost Bites (AfroCentric | Aspen | Novus – Mustek)

Aspen announced the disposal of Aspen APAC and the market loved it. AfroCentric is disposing of Activo and the market forgot to notice - for now, at least. And for Novus, a purchase of 3,000 shares has turned out to be very expensive in the Mustek deal.

UNLOCK THE STOCK: Southern Sun

In the 65th edition of Unlock the Stock, Southern Sun joined the platform to talk about the recent numbers and the strategic outlook for the business.

Ghost Bites (Mr Price | NEPI Rockcastle)

Mr Price isn't backing off on the NKD deal, despite the absolute hatred for the transaction from the market. NEPI's pre-close update shows the importance of looking at per-share growth.

Sponsored

Ghost Stories #89: 25 years of Satrix – how indexation changed investing in South Africa

In the year 2000, a lot happened. There was some questionable pop music. There was also the Dot-Com Crisis, followed by a period that saw incredible equity returns in South Africa until the Global Financial Crisis hit in 2007/2008. And during that important period in our local market, we also saw the emergence and initial growth of ETFs in South Africa, spearheaded by Satrix. To reflect on 25 years of ETFs in South Africa, René Basson joined me to share the important milestones and fascinating stories that defined this journey. Join us as we look back on how Satrix made it possible for everyone to own the market.

The Finance Ghost Plugged in with Capitec: Ep 6 (Noodles without borders – bringing miso to Mzansi)

Lu-ise Hattingh and Ruan Botha are a great example of the power and value of travel. After spending time in Japan, they fell in love with the culture and food. As all great entrepreneurs do, they also took the opportunity to learn about the Japanese approach to consumer brands. That curiosity eventually sparked a business idea they brought back home. Today, Lu-ise and Ruan are rolling out Market Kokoro franchise stores in South Africa.

Ghost Stories #88: Cell C – more than just an MVNO engine

Cell C has been on quite the adventure in its efforts to carve out a sustainable competitive position. Cell C has created a profitable business model that goes well beyond the MVNO operations that the market tends to focus on. In this podcast, CEO Jorge Mendes joined me to explain Cell C's business and how they plan to win across key verticals.

Ghost Stories #87: Lessons from 2025 – discipline over drama

As we look back on a fascinating year in the markets, Nico Katzke (Head of Portfolio Solutions at Satrix) delivered a fantastic mix of insights on this podcast that can be applied to your strategy in 2026 and beyond. From being careful not to learn the wrong lessons through to choosing simplicity over complexity, there's a lot of great stuff in here to get you ready for another year in the markets.